Skip to content

Fishing St. Croix ‘Forever & Always’ Charters

Experience a fishing trip you will remember 'Forever & Always'! Fishing St. Croix offers offshore or near-shore charters for up to six people. Whether you are a fishing novice or a pro, we can accommodate your needs. Our fun and professional crew will create a fun, safe and entertaining fishing experience for you. Catch marlin, mahi, tuna, wahoo, kingfish and more – and keep what you catch! 'Forever & Always' is located in Green Cay Marina, and transportation is available upon request. Make your reservations online today. Full and half day charters are available. Local discounts offered!

Location: East End
Phone: (340) 244-1335

World records have been set by sport fishermen here in the Caribbean.  We catch many migratory fish such as; Mahi, Wahoo, tuna, and marlin while trolling, and swordfish by deep-dropping.  Bottom and near-shore fishing brings us; blue runner, many types of snapper, tarpon and always a few surprises. Whatever you desire, whether it be near-shore or offshore, we do not have to travel far to start fishing.  Our team’s goal is to offer you a fun, safe, entertaining fishing experience. We strive to have each guest catch a great fish and experience a trip they will remember “Forever & Always”. 

Captains Barb and Tony Peel

This ocean going couple were brought together by their love of fishing in 1997.  They each possess a 100 ton Masters USCG License.  Together they have guided many fishing trips off the North Eastern coast of the United States. They fish a variety of tournaments and have brought in many winning catches on board their Charter boat Sushi Hunter. Barb’s best catch was a 500 lb Thresher Shark. Together they have fished the world. Tony is also an IGFA  Captain and observer.

  • Offshore Trips: Catch marlin, mahi, tuna, wahoo, and deep-drop for swordfish and other big game.
  • Near-shore Trips: Catch snapper, reef fish, jacks, and more.
  • Whether you are a fishing novice or a fishing pro, we can accommodate your needs. 
  • We fish up to six rods at a time when trolling
  • Equipment includes down rigger 625  Penn Phathom Master, Penn International and Shimano
  • You keep what you catch

Located on Green Cay Marina's F Dock, near Deep End Bar & Grille


Click here to check availability.

Read More about Fishing St. Croix "Forever & Always"

100 Things To Do on St. Croix

100 Things To Do on St. Croix We here at have compiled a list of ‘100 Things To Do on St. Croix’ featuring popular activities, attractions, and must-do experiences unique to St. Croix. St. Croix offers lots of things to do, thanks to our perfect weather and beautiful beaches. Our rum drinks are also…

Read More